If you’re in a fantasy baseball draft in 2025 and you’re not targeting second basemen with eligibility at other positions, you’re missing the boat.
The middle infield is absolutely flush with studs, but a closer look points you more toward shortstop than it does second base.
Once you get past names such as Mookie Betts, Jose Altuve and Ketel Marte, the pool of quality options dries up rapidly.
You can wait until the very end of your draft and land someone passable like Zack Gelof, or you can look to those with multi-position eligibility and find yourself someone of quality who narrowly qualifies at second base.
Guys such as Matt McLain of the Reds and Ceddanne Rafaela of the Red Sox are prime examples of how positional flexibility can turn your roster into a winner. This isn’t just about filling a spot, it’s about stacking advantages.
McLain is a stud, when he isn’t sidelined. In 2023, he gave us a taste of the good stuff: .290/.357/.507, 16 dingers, 14 swipes in just 89 games.
He is a natural shortstop, but with the arrival of Elly De La Cruz, McLain has moved to second base and played enough games to qualify there this season.
Sure, 2024 was a wash with injuries, but don’t let that scare you off. He has 20-20 written all over him if he stays on the field.
The Reds are a young, chaotic bunch, and McLain’s right in the thick of it, hitting behind speedsters like De La Cruz. Middle rounds, folks, that’s where you snag him. He is a potential league-winner if the injury gods play nice.
Then there’s Rafaela. This Red Sox spark plug is a wild card, and I’m here for it. In 2024, he mashed 15 homers, stole 17 bags and hit .253 while bouncing between center field and shortstop.
Second base eligibility? Check your platform because 10 games at second in 2024 are enough to qualify in most leagues. Rafaela’s a toolsy freak, speed for days, pop in the bat, and a glove that keeps him in the lineup.
The downside?
That .278 OBP screams “work in progress.” But if he figures out the strike zone, we’re talking 15-25 upside, easy.
Learn all you need to know about MLB Betting
Late rounds, he’s your gamble. Outfield and infield eligibility? That’s roster gold, baby!
Don’t stop there. Detroit’s Colt Keith — second and third base — smacked his way to relevance in 2024 and could be a sleeper. Jake Cronenworth?
First and second (sometimes shortstop) with a steady bat. Even Whit Merrifield’s old legs still bring second and outfield value. These guys aren’t just players, they’re chess pieces.
Here’s the deal: Versatility wins titles. McLain’s your high-ceiling stud, Rafaela’s your dart throw with swagger, and the others fill gaps like champs. Draft smart, stack that flexibility, and watch your roster bend the league to your will.
Howard Bender is the head of content at FantasyAlarm.com. Follow him on X @rotobuzzguy and catch him on the award-winning “Fantasy Alarm Radio Show” on the SiriusXM fantasy sports channel weekdays from 6-8 p.m. Go to FantasyAlarm.com for all your fantasy baseball news and advice.
